High-yield points
- SM: size 1–3, eloquence 0–1, deep drainage 0–1, giving grades I–V .
- Spetzler–Ponce: A (I–II) surgery; B (III) multimodality; C (IV–V) observe unless there is recurrent hemorrhage or progressive deficit .
- Supplementary: age 1–3 (children 1), unruptured +1, diffuse +1 .
- Combined ≤6 is the generally accepted boundary for acceptable surgical risk .
Landmark papers
- Spetzler–Martin grade (Spetzler and Martin, J Neurosurg 1986): the original grading system, scoring nidus size, eloquence of adjacent brain and venous drainage into grades I–V. It predicts surgical morbidity .
- Supplementary (Lawton–Young) grade (Lawton et al., Neurosurgery 2010): derived in 300 patients from a single surgeon. ROC area was 0.73 for the supplementary grade vs 0.65 for SM (P = .042) .
- Multicenter validation (Kim et al., Neurosurgery 2015): 1,009 patients at 4 centers. ROC area was 0.75 vs 0.69 for the combined grade vs SM (P < .001) .
Use this to grade a brain arteriovenous malformation before choosing treatment.
- Spetzler–Martin (SM) grade: scores nidus size, eloquence of adjacent brain and venous drainage, giving grades I–V. It predicts surgical morbidity .
- Spetzler–Ponce classes: collapse SM into three treatment tiers .
- Supplementary (Lawton–Young) grade: adds age, presentation and nidal diffuseness .
- Combined (Supp-SM) grade: predicts neurological outcome after surgery better than SM alone .
Pick one option in each group.
Open the interactive calculator in the book →
Scoring
- Spetzler–Martin (range I–V) :
- Size: under 3 cm 1; 3–6 cm 2; over 6 cm 3.
- Eloquent adjacent brain: no 0; yes 1.
- Deep venous drainage: no 0; yes 1.
- Supplementary (range I–V) :
- Age: under 20 years 1; 20–40 years 2; over 40 years 3.
- Presentation: ruptured 0; unruptured 1.
- Nidus: compact 0; diffuse 1.
- Deep perforating artery supply was in the full statistical model but is not scored in the supplementary grade .
- Combined grade = SM + supplementary (range up to 10) .
- Worked example from the derivation paper: a 57-year-old with an unruptured, 2 cm, compact, eloquent AVM with superficial drainage. That is SM grade II and supplementary grade IV, so combined 6 .
Interpreting the grades
- Spetzler–Ponce three-tier classes :
- Class A (SM I–II): surgery.
- Class B (SM III): multimodality treatment.
- Class C (SM IV–V): observation, with exceptions for recurrent hemorrhage or progressive neurological deficit.
- Accuracy: in 1,476 pooled surgical patients, the three-tier and five-tier systems predicted outcome equally well (ROC area 0.713 vs. 0.711).
- Supplementary grade adds accuracy:
- Derivation (300 patients, single surgeon): ROC area 0.73 for the supplementary grade vs. 0.65 for SM (P = .042) .
- Validation (1,009 patients, 4 centers): 0.75 vs. 0.69 for the combined grade vs. SM (P < .001) .
- Risk by combined grade in the derivation series, shown as the share of patients worse or dead at final follow-up by modified Rankin Scale (mRS) :
- ≤3: none (0 of 28);
- 4: 9.1%;
- 5: 21.1%;
- 6: 27.1%;
- 7: 54.5%;
- 8 and 9: 40–50%, but in only 13 patients.
- The operability boundary is a combined grade of 6:
- ≤6: acceptably low surgical risk (0–24%).
- Over 6: risk rose to 39–63% .
In children
- Every patient under 20 scores the minimum 1 point for age . Children therefore tend to have lower combined grades than adults with the same SM grade.
- A ruptured presentation scores 0 . Hemorrhage is the commonest presentation in children (see Brain AVMs), so this also lowers pediatric grades.
- The grades were derived and validated in mostly adult surgical series . Use them to frame risk, alongside angioarchitecture and the family's goals. See Brain AVMs in this section for pediatric outcomes by treatment.
Related topics
- Brain AVMs in Children: presentation, natural history, treatment and recurrence.
- Cerebral Proliferative Angiopathy: a diffuse AVM mimic that grading does not fit.
- Spinal AVM and AV Fistula Classifier (Kim–Spetzler, Type I–IV and Bicêtre): classifying spinal AVMs and fistulas.
- Craniotomy for Arteriovenous Malformation: step-by-step procedure.
References
- Spetzler RF, Martin NA. A proposed grading system for arteriovenous malformations. J Neurosurg 1986;65(4):476–483. doi:10.3171/jns.1986.65.4.0476. PMID 3760956. verified
- Spetzler RF, Ponce FA. A 3-tier classification of cerebral arteriovenous malformations. J Neurosurg 2011;114(3):842–849. doi:10.3171/2010.8.JNS10663. PMID 20932095. verified
- Lawton MT, Kim H, McCulloch CE, Mikhak B, Young WL. A supplementary grading scale for selecting patients with brain arteriovenous malformations for surgery. Neurosurgery 2010;66(4):702–713. doi:10.1227/01.NEU.0000367555.16733.E1. PMID 20190666. Full text (PMC) verified
- Kim H, Abla AA, Nelson J, et al. Validation of the supplemented Spetzler-Martin grading system for brain arteriovenous malformations in a multicenter cohort of 1009 surgical patients. Neurosurgery 2015;76(1):25–31. doi:10.1227/NEU.0000000000000556. PMID 25251197. verified
Verification (2026-11-16):
- Each reference's authors, title, journal, year, volume, pages, DOI and PMID were checked on PubMed.
- Numbers from references 2 and 4 were checked against their abstracts.
- The SM and supplementary point values were confirmed in the open-access full text of reference 3 (PMC2847513, Table 1). That source also gave:
- the scoring of age, presentation and diffuseness only;
- the worked example;
- the combined-grade outcomes (Table 5).
Caveats:
- The list of eloquent regions in the calculator is the standard Spetzler–Martin definition, not checked against reference 1's full text.
- The pediatric remarks are this text's reading of the scoring rules, not pediatric validation data.