High-yield points
- One guideline for all ages (2023). Not applicable under 37 weeks' corrected gestational age .
- Children: 2 clinicians, 2 examinations at least 12 h apart, 2 apnea tests .
- Prerequisites:
- wait 48 h if under 24 months, or 24 h after hypoxic-ischemic injury;
- core temperature ≥36 °C, with a 24-hour wait after cooling;
- SBP and MAP at or above the 5th percentile;
- drug clearance of at least 5 half-lives;
- no neuromuscular blockade .
- Apnea test is positive with no breathing, pH <7.30, and PaCO2 ≥60 and ≥20 above baseline .
- Ancillary tests: flow studies only. EEG no longer counts. Never use an ancillary test to bypass a prerequisite .
- Posterior fossa lesion: confirm catastrophic supratentorial injury first .
- Local law and hospital policy also apply. Align your institutional protocol with the 2023 guideline .
Landmark papers
- 2023 AAN/AAP/CNS/SCCM consensus guideline (Greer et al., Neurology 2023): replaced both the 2010 adult and the 2011 pediatric guidelines with one process for all ages. In children it requires 2 examinations by 2 different clinicians at least 12 hours apart, each followed by an apnea test .
Brain death, or death by neurologic criteria (BD/DNC), is a clinical diagnosis. It rests on permanent loss of all brain function, including the brainstem, from a known cause .
- The current US standard: the 2023 AAN/AAP/CNS/SCCM consensus guideline. It replaced both the 2010 adult and the 2011 pediatric guidelines with one process for all ages .
- Its emphasis: be conservative, and delay or defer whenever a prerequisite is not met, to avoid a false-positive determination .
- In children: 2 examinations by 2 different clinicians at least 12 hours apart, each followed by an apnea test .
Who can be evaluated
- Age: BD/DNC cannot be determined in infants under 37 weeks' corrected gestational age. A "child" is 37 weeks' corrected age to under 18 years .
- Cause: a known, irreversible catastrophic brain injury .
- Posterior fossa injury: with a primary posterior fossa lesion, first confirm on imaging that it has also caused catastrophic supratentorial injury .
Prerequisites (2023)
- Time after the injury :
- Under 24 months: wait at least 48 hours after the acute brain injury.
- 24 months or older with hypoxic-ischemic injury: wait at least 24 hours.
- Other causes: wait a sufficient time.
- Temperature :
- Core temperature ≥36 °C (the 2011 pediatric threshold was 35 °C).
- After cooling to 35.5 °C or below: wait 24 hours after rewarming to ≥36 °C. Ancillary testing cannot be used to bypass this wait .
- Blood pressure :
- Adults: SBP ≥100 mm Hg and MAP ≥75 mm Hg.
- Children: SBP and MAP at or above the 5th percentile for age.
- Both values must now meet the threshold.
- Drugs :
- Toxicology: negative when indicated; alcohol ≤80 mg/dL.
- Clearance: drug levels therapeutic or lower, or allow at least 5 half-lives for CNS depressants, and longer with renal or hepatic dysfunction, obesity or hypothermia.
- Pentobarbital: level <5 μg/mL.
- Exclude severe metabolic, acid-base and endocrine derangements .
- Exclude neuromuscular blockade with a train-of-four stimulator, or by demonstrating deep tendon reflexes .
The examination
- Every element that can be assessed must be assessed . Any finding inconsistent with BD/DNC means the criteria are not met.
- Required findings :
- Coma: no response to visual, auditory or tactile stimulation.
- No motor responses of the head, face, neck or limbs, other than spinally mediated reflexes.
- Pupils: no reaction to bright light, bilaterally.
- Eye-movement reflexes:
- Oculocephalic reflex: absent. Test it only if the cervical spine and skull base are intact.
- Oculovestibular (cold caloric) reflex: absent, tested bilaterally whenever the oculocephalic reflex is absent or untestable.
- Corneal, gag and cough reflexes: absent bilaterally.
- Infants under 6 months: no sucking or rooting reflex.
- Examiners and timing :
- Children: two clinicians, each doing a separate, independent examination, at least 12 hours apart. This applies to all children, whatever their age. In 2011 the interval was 24 hours under 30 days of age.
- Ancillary testing no longer shortens this interval .
- Adults: one examination; a second clinician may examine independently.
Apnea test
- How many :
- Children: two, one after each examination.
- Adults: at least one.
- Before starting :
- Patient: not hypoxemic, hypotensive or hypovolemic.
- Baseline gases: PaCO2 35–45 mm Hg and pH 7.35–7.45, unless the patient has known chronic hypercarbia.
- Preoxygenation: 100% oxygen for at least 10 minutes, to PaO2 >200 mm Hg.
- Procedure :
- Gases: an arterial gas before disconnection, then again after 8–10 minutes of apnea.
- Expected rise: PaCO2 climbs about 2–3 mm Hg per minute.
- Positive (consistent with BD/DNC) :
- no respiratory effort;
- pH <7.30;
- PaCO2 ≥60 mm Hg and ≥20 mm Hg above baseline.
- The pH criterion is new; the 2011 pediatric guideline had none .
- Abort the test for :
- any spontaneous breath;
- hypotension (adults: SBP <100 or MAP <75 mm Hg; children: at or below the 5th percentile);
- oxygen saturation falling progressively below 85%;
- unstable arrhythmia.
- On ECMO :
- Preoxygenation: through the membrane lung and the ventilator.
- Raising CO2: lower the sweep gas to 0.2–1 L/min, or add exogenous CO2.
- Sampling on VA ECMO: gases from both the patient's distal arterial line and the post-oxygenator circuit.
- Sampling on VV ECMO: gases from the distal arterial line only.
Ancillary tests
- Not a shortcut. Use them only when the examination or apnea test cannot be completed or interpreted . Examples:
- cervical spine, skull base or orbital fractures;
- an unsafe apnea test;
- metabolic derangements that cannot be corrected.
- Never in place of the prerequisites:
- not in the setting of hypothermia or high sedative levels;
- not just because of an open fontanelle, a skull defect or a CSF shunt .
- Acceptable tests: blood-flow studies only :
- 4-vessel catheter angiography;
- radionuclide perfusion scintigraphy, SPECT or planar;
- transcranial Doppler, in adults only.
- No longer acceptable :
- EEG, evoked potentials, CT angiography and MRI/MRA.
- EEG was acceptable in the 2011 pediatric guideline.
What changed from the 2011 pediatric guideline
- 2011 framework :
- Examinations: two, each with an apnea test, by different attending physicians.
- Observation intervals: 24 hours (term newborn to 30 days) or 12 hours (over 30 days).
- Apnea target: PaCO2 ≥60 mm Hg and ≥20 above baseline.
- Ancillary tests: EEG or radionuclide flow, which could shorten the interval.
- 2023 changes :
- Interval: 12 hours for all children.
- Temperature: ≥36 °C, with a 24-hour wait after rewarming.
- Blood pressure: both SBP and MAP.
- Apnea test: adds the pH <7.30 criterion.
- Ancillary tests: EEG removed, transcranial Doppler for adults only, and ancillary tests no longer shorten the interval.
- New guidance on ECMO and posterior fossa injury.
Related topics
- Anoxic Brain Injury and Neonatal HIE: the usual cause in drowning and arrest.
- Having Difficult Conversations: talking with families about death.
- Abusive Head Trauma: a common cause in infants.
- Bioethics: Challenging Situations in Pediatric Neurosurgery: ethical frameworks for hard decisions.
References
- Greer DM, Kirschen MP, Lewis A, et al. Pediatric and adult brain death/death by neurologic criteria consensus guideline. Neurology 2023;101(24):1112–1132. doi:10.1212/WNL.0000000000207740. PMID 37821233. Full text (PMC) verified
- Lewis A, Kirschen MP, Greer D. The 2023 AAN/AAP/CNS/SCCM pediatric and adult brain death/death by neurologic criteria consensus practice guideline: a comparison with the 2010 and 2011 guidelines. Neurol Clin Pract 2023;13(6):e200189. doi:10.1212/CPJ.0000000000200189. PMID 37829552. Full text (PMC) verified
- Nakagawa TA, Ashwal S, Mathur M, et al. Clinical report—Guidelines for the determination of brain death in infants and children: an update of the 1987 task force recommendations. Pediatrics 2011;128(3):e720–e740. doi:10.1542/peds.2011-1511. PMID 21873704. verified
Verification (2026-11-16):
- Each reference's authors, title, journal, year, volume, pages, DOI and PMID were checked on PubMed.
- Recommendations and thresholds come from the open-access full texts of references 1 (Recommendations 1–40) and 2 (comparison tables and text).
- The 2011 details come from reference 3's abstract.
- Reference 1 carries a published correction (Neurology 2024;102(3):e208108), which was not reviewed.
Caveats:
- The ice-water volume and observation time for caloric testing were not stated in the text read, so they are omitted.
- Legal requirements differ by state and country.
- The figure is an original schematic.