High-yield points
- Gaps are real:
- Black and Hispanic children with drug-resistant epilepsy have lower odds of surgery (OR 0.51 and 0.68) ;
- non-English speakers face delays to surgery in 75% of studies .
- Professional, trained interpreters cut consequential errors (12% vs 22% ad hoc; 2% with 100 hours or more of training) . Never use a child as interpreter.
- Spanish-speaking parents ask fewer questions. Invite them, use teach-back, and give materials in their language .
- Parental misperception and physician communication are the most frequently reported barrier categories for epilepsy surgery .
- Jehovah's Witness families: plan blood conservation early. Transfusion-free vault surgery is feasible in selected cases .
- Cultural humility: ask about beliefs, include the real decision-makers, and address structural needs.
Children don't reach the operating room equally. Language, culture, beliefs, trust and social circumstances shape:
- whether a child is referred;
- what a family understands;
- what they consent to;
- how quickly they get surgery.
The gaps are measurable in neurosurgery and in pediatric epilepsy surgery . Many of them are modifiable at the bedside .
See also Having Difficult Conversations in this section.
The evidence that gaps exist
- Language (systematic review of 10 studies, 973 adult and pediatric neurosurgical patients whose primary language was not English) :
- 75% of studies found a delay to surgery, or a lower chance of receiving it;
- all 3 studies reporting length of stay found it longer.
- Epilepsy surgery: a clear example.
- National data (29,292 patients with medically intractable epilepsy, Kids' Inpatient Database) :
- African American children had about half the odds of surgical treatment (OR 0.51);
- Hispanic children had lower odds too (OR 0.68);
- Medicaid/Medicare was associated with lower odds (OR 0.60) than private insurance;
- insurance alone did not explain the gap: privately insured African American (OR 0.71) and Hispanic (OR 0.67) children still had lower odds than privately insured White children;
- African American and Hispanic children used the emergency department more.
- Systematic review :
- children evaluated for surgery were most often White, privately insured, with college-educated caregivers;
- of the 5 studies that examined race, most found longer times to referral or surgery, or lower surgical rates, for Hispanic and/or non-White children.
- Scoping review of barriers to epilepsy surgery :
- parental barriers (misperceptions, little knowledge of outcomes, emotional vulnerability) appeared in 76% of studies;
- physician barriers (communication, trust, inadequate consent and referral) in 65%.
- Read these carefully: race and ethnicity are social, not biological, categories. These gaps likely reflect structural factors (including racism, insurance and referral patterns) and communication, which these studies cannot separate (see caveats).
Barriers, and what to do about each
Language
- What families and staff report (Spanish-speaking parents and providers) :
- Spanish-speaking parents asked fewer questions and raised fewer concerns, yet wanted to understand their child's future needs;
- high-quality Spanish-language education materials were scarce;
- parents and providers both preferred in-person interpreters, which were often unavailable.
- Use professional interpreters, not family members or bilingual staff without training :
- Who: Spanish-speaking families in pediatric emergency departments.
- Errors with potential clinical consequences:
- 12% with professional interpreters;
- 22% with ad hoc interpreters;
- 20% with none.
- Training matters: among professional interpreters (57 encounters studied overall), those with 100 hours or more of training made far fewer consequential errors (2% vs 12% for those with less training).
- At the bedside (see caveats):
- never use a child or sibling as interpreter;
- speak to the family, not the interpreter;
- use short segments and plain words;
- teach-back to confirm understanding;
- give written instructions in the family's language;
- schedule extra time.
- Consent discussions for elective surgery should wait until a qualified interpreter is available.
Health literacy and understanding of disease
- What it looks like: a family may not see why surgery is offered for a condition that seems stable. Examples:
- craniosynostosis "only for shape";
- epilepsy surgery when seizures are "controlled enough";
- a fatty filum in a child who is well.
- Parental barriers (misperceptions, limited knowledge of surgical outcomes and emotional vulnerability) are the most frequently reported category of barrier to epilepsy surgery (76% of studies) .
- Approach (see caveats):
- explain the natural history without surgery as clearly as the risks of surgery;
- use pictures and models;
- offer to speak with other families, or with community or faith leaders, if the family wishes.
Beliefs, stigma and traditional care
- Beliefs about cause: in some communities, epilepsy, hydrocephalus or spina bifida carry stigma or are attributed to spiritual causes.
- Families may seek traditional or religious healing first, or alongside medical care (see caveats).
- Approach:
- ask, don't assume: "What do you think is causing this?" and "What worries you most?";
- integrate harmless practices rather than dismissing them;
- focus on shared goals for the child.
Religious values: blood products
- A classic neurosurgical example: families who are Jehovah's Witnesses and decline blood transfusion.
- Elective, high-blood-loss operations such as calvarial vault remodeling raise ethical tension: parental autonomy against the surgeon's duty of beneficence to the child .
- Transfusion-free vault reconstruction is possible :
- two pediatric cases;
- multimodal blood conservation, including antifibrinolytics.
- Practical approach (see caveats):
- plan early, ideally with a hospital liaison;
- preoperative hemoglobin optimization (iron, erythropoietin);
- antifibrinolytics;
- cell salvage (if acceptable to the family);
- meticulous hemostasis;
- minimally invasive techniques (endoscopic strip craniectomy for synostosis);
- know your institutional and legal process for life-threatening emergencies in minors.
Trust and family decision-making
- Mistrust shaped by past and ongoing discrimination, or by experiences with health systems, can delay consent (see caveats).
- The decision-makers may not be in the room. In many families, decisions involve grandparents, elders or the wider family.
- Invite them.
- Don't force a decision at the first visit for non-urgent surgery.
- Physician-side barriers (communication, trust, referral) are reported almost as often as parental ones (65% vs 76% of studies) .
Structural barriers
- Insurance, income and education are associated with who gets epilepsy surgery .
- Other practical obstacles:
- transport and time off work for multiple visits;
- immigration-related fears.
- Approach:
- involve social work early;
- cluster appointments;
- use telehealth where appropriate;
- patient navigators.
Related topics
- Having Difficult Conversations: communication skills that complement interpreter use and teach-back.
- Epilepsy Surgery in Children: Overview: the surgery where access gaps are best documented.
- Estimation of Blood Volume in Children: planning blood conservation.
- The Fatty Filum: an example of surgery for a seemingly stable child.
- Bioethics: Challenging Situations in Pediatric Neurosurgery: ethical frameworks for hard decisions.
References
- Ruiz Colón GD, Bereknyei Merrell S, Poon DC, et al. Language-discordant care in pediatric neurosurgery: parent and provider perspectives on challenges and multilevel solutions to reduce disparities. J Neurosurg Pediatr 2024;33(6):619–625. doi:10.3171/2024.1.PEDS23435. PMID 38518279. verified
- Ruiz Colón GD, Barros Guinle MI, Wu A, et al. Neurosurgical outcomes among non-English speakers: a systematic review and a framework for future research. World Neurosurg 2024;185:338–350.e1. doi:10.1016/j.wneu.2024.02.068. PMID 38387790. verified
- Kandregula S, Terrell D, Beyl R, et al. Racial and socioeconomic disparities in the advanced treatment of medically intractable pediatric epilepsy. Neurosurg Focus 2022;53(4):E2. doi:10.3171/2022.7.FOCUS22338. PMID 36183182. verified
- Flores G, Abreu M, Barone CP, et al. Errors of medical interpretation and their potential clinical consequences: a comparison of professional versus ad hoc versus no interpreters. Ann Emerg Med 2012;60(5):545–553. doi:10.1016/j.annemergmed.2012.01.025. PMID 22424655. verified
- Winterhalter E, LoPresti MA, Widjaja E, et al. The impact of social determinants of health on utilization of pediatric epilepsy surgery: a systematic review. J Neurosurg Pediatr 2024;34(1):30–39. doi:10.3171/2024.1.PEDS23128. PMID 38579357. verified
- Hatoum R, Nathoo-Khedri N, Shlobin NA, et al. Barriers to epilepsy surgery in pediatric patients: a scoping review. Seizure 2022;102:83–95. doi:10.1016/j.seizure.2022.08.013. PMID 36209677. verified
- Linkugel AD, Yu J, Kopar PK, et al. A case of nonsyndromic craniosynostosis in an infant child of Jehovah's Witness parents: is surgical correction appropriate? Cleft Palate Craniofac J 2023;60(3):280–284. doi:10.1177/10556656211062036. PMID 34812088. verified
- Reddy SK, Swink JM, Rogers GF, et al. Transfusion-free calvarial vault reconstruction using multimodal blood conservation strategies in two pediatric Jehovah's Witness patients with craniosynostosis. A A Case Rep 2016;7(2):33–36. doi:10.1213/XAA.0000000000000334. PMID 27224036. verified
Verification (2026-11-17):
- Each reference's authors, title, journal, year, volume, pages, DOI and PMID were checked on PubMed. Numbers were checked against the PubMed abstracts.
Caveats:
- Much of this topic is practical guidance rather than trial evidence. The following are standard practice and expert consensus, not drawn from the cited abstracts:
- the bedside interpreter techniques (teach-back, triadic seating, never using children);
- waiting for an interpreter before elective consent;
- the health-literacy, beliefs and stigma, trust and family decision-making approaches;
- the blood-conservation options and emergency legal processes;
- the structural supports;
- the barrier observations on mistrust, transport and time off work, and immigration-related fears;
- fear of brain surgery as a parental concern.
- Reference 4 studied emergency department encounters, not neurosurgery specifically.
- Reference 3 is an administrative database study that cannot measure the reasons behind the disparities.
- Stigma and traditional-healing statements are general observations, not drawn from cited data.
- Framing race and ethnicity as social categories whose gaps reflect structural factors and communication is the author's interpretation; the cited studies do not test mechanisms.
- The figure is an original schematic.