High-yield points
- Spasticity: resistance that increases with stretch speed and has a catch (NIH definition) .
- Dystonia: involuntary sustained or intermittent contractions with twisting postures, triggered or worsened by voluntary action, with overflow .
- Bedside contrast:
- Spasticity: compare a fast with a slow stretch.
- Dystonia: have the child move a distant limb and watch the posture change.
- Fluctuation: worse with effort and emotion, better in sleep, which favors dystonia.
- Spasticity and dystonia coexist in most children with CP. Dystonia is common even in "spastic" CP and worsens with lower function .
- HAT: reliable for spasticity, moderate for dystonia .
- Surgical consequence: SDR treats spasticity, not dystonia. Dystonia points toward ITB or GPi DBS.
Spasticity and dystonia are the two commonest forms of pediatric hypertonia, and they often coexist, especially in cerebral palsy (CP) .
- Why the distinction matters for neurosurgeons: the treatments diverge.
- Spasticity: selective dorsal rhizotomy (SDR) and intrathecal baclofen (ITB) reduce it.
- Dystonia: SDR does not help. ITB and pallidal deep brain stimulation (DBS) are the options (see Surgical Management of Spasticity and DBS for Dystonia).
- The bedside rule:
- Spasticity depends on how fast you stretch.
- Dystonia depends on what the child is doing: it is driven by voluntary action, posture and overflow .
Definitions (NIH consensus for childhood hypertonia)
- Spasticity: hypertonia in which one or both of the following are present :
- resistance increases with the speed of stretch and varies with the direction of movement;
- resistance rises sharply above a threshold speed or joint angle (the "catch").
- Dystonia: a movement disorder defined by involuntary muscle contractions, either sustained or intermittent, that produce twisting, repetitive movements and/or abnormal postures .
- Adult movement-disorder consensus definition (2013, revised 2025) :
- the movements follow a recurring pattern, and can look tremulous or jerky;
- voluntary action commonly triggers or aggravates them;
- they are frequently associated with overflow.
- Rigidity (much rarer in children): resistance
- is present at very low speeds and does not depend on speed or have a threshold;
- is felt immediately on reversing direction, from co-contraction;
- without a tendency to return to a fixed posture.
Mechanisms
- Spasticity: the upper motor neuron syndrome.
- The lesion: damage to the corticospinal and parallel reticulospinal pathways, for example periventricular leukomalacia in preterm diplegia.
- The result: the spinal stretch reflex loses its descending inhibition. The Ia-afferent–α-motor-neuron reflex becomes hyperexcitable and fires more at higher stretch velocities.
- Accompanying signs: hyperreflexia, clonus, Babinski signs and weakness.
- Treatment targets this spinal mechanism (see the figure):
- SDR cuts part of the afferent limb;
- ITB enhances GABA-B inhibition in the dorsal horn.
- Dystonia: a network disorder.
- The circuit: the basal ganglia–thalamo–cortical motor loop and its cerebellar connections.
- Typical injuries: hypoxic-ischemic damage to the putamen and thalamus, kernicterus, and genetic or metabolic disease.
- The motor control error: loss of surround inhibition and selectivity, which produces co-contraction of agonists and antagonists and overflow into muscles not needed for the task.
- Treatment targets the network: pallidal (GPi) DBS or ITB. Rhizotomy has no role.
- Mixed tone is the rule in CP. In 151 children assessed with the Hypertonia Assessment Tool (HAT) :
- Dystonia was common even in children classed as spastic.
- Severity: dystonia grew more severe as gross motor, manual and communication function worsened.
Telling them apart at the bedside
- Change the speed of stretch (spasticity):
- Fast passive stretch gives more resistance, often with a catch at a threshold angle (the Tardieu principle: compare a slow with a fast stretch). Slow stretch gives little.
- Direction-dependent: for example, worse into elbow extension than flexion .
- Change the task, not the stretch (dystonia):
- Distant movement: tone or posture increases when the child moves a distant body part. Ask them to open and close the opposite hand, or to talk or reach.
- Action-induced posturing: the fist clenches, the arm pronates, the foot inverts, the neck twists.
- Overflow: mirror or overflow movements appear .
- Variability: tone varies with state. It is worse with excitement, pain, effort or upright posture, and eases in sleep or when relaxed.
- Tactile and positional triggers (see caveats).
- No reliable speed dependence or catch with dystonia: resistance may be present at slow speeds and fluctuate.
- Rigidity: lead-pipe resistance at any speed, equal in both directions.
- Structured tools:
- Hypertonia Assessment Tool (HAT) :
- What it is: seven bedside items that classify spasticity, dystonia and rigidity.
- Reliability: excellent for spasticity and for excluding rigidity, but only moderate for dystonia (kappa about 0.4–0.6).
- Prevalence in the development cohort: spasticity in 87% and dystonia in 78%.
- Barry–Albright Dystonia Scale: rates dystonia severity .
- Modified Ashworth Scale: rates resistance but does not distinguish spasticity from dystonia (see caveats).
- Imaging:
- Periventricular white matter injury points to spasticity.
- Basal ganglia or thalamic injury, for example hypoxic-ischemic, points to dystonia (see caveats).
Why it changes management
- Pure spasticity, ambulant child (GMFCS II–III): consider SDR (see Surgical Management of Spasticity).
- Dystonia or mixed tone:
- Avoid SDR for the dystonic component.
- Options: ITB, which beat placebo on individual goals in severe dyskinetic CP, and GPi DBS (see DBS for Dystonia).
- ITB catheter tip: placed higher for upper-limb and generalized tone.
- Botulinum toxin helps focal spasticity and focal dystonia alike.
Related topics
- Surgical Management of Spasticity: BoNT-A, phenol, ITB and SDR.
- DBS for Dystonia: pallidal DBS outcomes.
- Principles of Pediatric Neuro-Rehabilitation: rehabilitation principles after injury and surgery.
- Intrathecal Baclofen Pump Implantation: step-by-step procedure.
- Botulinum Toxin Injection for Spasticity: Common Sites: step-by-step procedure.
- GPi Deep Brain Stimulation: Procedure and Targeting: step-by-step procedure.
References
- Jethwa A, Mink J, Macarthur C, et al. Development of the Hypertonia Assessment Tool (HAT): a discriminative tool for hypertonia in children. Dev Med Child Neurol 2010;52(5):e83–e87. doi:10.1111/j.1469-8749.2009.03483.x. PMID 20540176. verified
- Rice J, Skuza P, Baker F, et al. Identification and measurement of dystonia in cerebral palsy. Dev Med Child Neurol 2017;59(12):1249–1255. doi:10.1111/dmcn.13502. PMID 28786476. verified
- Sanger TD, Delgado MR, Gaebler-Spira D, et al. Classification and definition of disorders causing hypertonia in childhood. Pediatrics 2003;111(1):e89–e97. doi:10.1542/peds.111.1.e89. PMID 12509602. verified
- Albanese A, Bhatia K, Bressman SB, et al. Phenomenology and classification of dystonia: a consensus update. Mov Disord 2013;28(7):863–873. doi:10.1002/mds.25475. PMID 23649720. verified
- Albanese A, Bhatia KP, Fung VSC, et al. Definition and classification of dystonia. Mov Disord 2025;40(7):1248–1259. doi:10.1002/mds.30220. PMID 40326714. verified
- Knights S, Datoo N, Kawamura A, et al. Further evaluation of the scoring, reliability, and validity of the Hypertonia Assessment Tool (HAT). J Child Neurol 2014;29(4):500–504. doi:10.1177/0883073813483903. PMID 23584688. verified
Verification (2026-11-16):
- Each reference's authors, title, journal, year, volume, pages, DOI and PMID were checked on PubMed, and every definition and number against the PubMed abstract.
Caveats:
- The following are standard teaching, not drawn from the cited abstracts:
- the mechanisms (loss of descending inhibition; basal ganglia network dysfunction, surround inhibition);
- the bedside maneuvers (Tardieu-style fast vs. slow stretch, distant-limb activation, state dependence);
- the observation that the Modified Ashworth Scale does not discriminate spasticity from dystonia;
- the imaging correlates;
- the specific HAT item content;
- the treatment implications (the ITB and SDR evidence is cited in the spasticity surgery topic).
- The figure is an original schematic.