High-yield points
- VACTERL is at least 3 of 6 components and a diagnosis of exclusion (think Fanconi anemia). Tethered cord and bladder dysfunction are associated features .
- Screen every ARM patient's spine, whatever the ARM type . A normal sacrum does not exclude a tether .
- Infant ultrasound triages but does not exclude. Abnormal findings go to MRI, and a normal scan does not end surveillance .
- Symptomatic tethered cord → untether. For asymptomatic tethering there is no consensus: European surgeons mostly observe , while 59.1% of responding US pediatric neurosurgeons would offer prophylactic detethering .
- Untethering improves motor and orthopedic symptoms but rarely bowel and bladder function in ARM .
VACTERL (older name VATER) is a non-random co-occurrence of malformations, not a single syndrome. Its causes are heterogeneous and mostly unknown . For the neurosurgeon it matters because the V (vertebral) and A (anal) components travel with spinal cord anomalies, and tethered cord is now listed among its associated features .
The practical questions are:
- whom to screen, and with what;
- whom to untether;
- what untethering can and cannot fix.
VACTERL: definition and workup
- The six components:
- Vertebral anomalies;
- Anal atresia (anorectal malformation, ARM);
- Cardiac malformations;
- Tracheo-Esophageal fistula, with or without esophageal atresia;
- Renal anomalies;
- Limb abnormalities (classically radial ray).
- Definition: usually at least 3 of the 6 .
- Patients with 2 components may belong to the same spectrum.
- Associated (non-core) features: single umbilical artery, tethered spinal cord and genital malformations .
- It is a diagnosis of exclusion. Rule out disorders with overlapping features before applying the label:
- Fanconi anemia (radial ray plus marrow failure);
- chromosomal and other single-gene syndromes.
- Genetic workup (2026 systematic review) :
- Reported diagnostic yields: chromosomal microarray 2–31%; exome sequencing 5–22%.
- Suggested for patients with 2 or more VACTERL features:
- imaging;
- complete blood count and film;
- microarray;
- chromosomal breakage studies;
- exome or genome sequencing.
- Bladder dysfunction is common :
- It is most prevalent with genital anomalies, ARM, sacral dysplasia, renal anomalies and tethered cord.
- The authors advise monitoring for it until urinary continence is achieved.
- The spinal cord in a VACTERL cohort (186 patients from an institutional database, 1993–2023) :
- 75.8% had a tethered cord and 23.7% a syrinx.
- Most syrinxes were explained by the tether and/or a Chiari malformation; 4 of 186 (2.2%) were idiopathic.
- All syrinxes were managed conservatively; all but one shrank or stayed stable.
- Expect referral bias: a single tertiary-center cohort may overstate prevalence.
Tethered cord in anorectal malformations
- Prevalence: reported figures range from 9% to 64% , depending on definition and imaging.
- Dutch cohort, 234 ARM patients imaged :
- spinal cord anomalies in 22.2%;
- tethered cord in 8.1% (19 patients), of whom 4 were untethered without complication.
- Italian cohort, 348 patients :
- spinal cord anomalies on MRI in 147;
- spinal dysraphism was the commonest type (94 of 147), and 96% of these were a fatty filum.
- Every ARM type is at risk. Spinal cord anomalies were found across simple, intermediate and complex ARM types .
- Higher ARM level correlated with spinal cord anomalies in one series ; another found no relationship with ARM type .
- Bony anomalies raise the odds but do not exclude:
- Spinal cord anomalies were found in 70% of patients with vertebral anomalies and 76% of those with sacral anomalies .
- Children without bony anomalies also had them, so a normal sacrum does not clear the cord .
- Embryology: in ARM, the spinal dysraphisms seen were only those arising after primary neurulation (secondary neurulation). This timing matches cloacal septation and suggests a single insult causes both .
- Expect filar lesions, low conus, terminal lipoma and caudal regression, not open myelomeningocele.
Screening: ultrasound versus MRI
- Neonatal spinal ultrasound (before the posterior elements ossify, roughly the first 3–4 months):
- van den Hondel :
- sensitivity 80%, specificity 89%;
- PPV 47%, NPV 97%.
- Jehangir :
- sensitivity 91% and specificity 75% against MRI;
- no child with a normal ultrasound later needed untethering.
- Systematic review, pooled for clinically relevant anomalies :
- infant ultrasound sensitivity only 33% (specificity 87%);
- a normal early ultrasound "does not have diagnostic weight".
- Practical reading:
- an abnormal or borderline ultrasound mandates MRI ;
- a normal one does not end surveillance .
- MRI is the reference standard.
- Pooled against surgery: sensitivity 97% and specificity 94% .
- Whether every infant gets MRI depends on the local stance on prophylactic untethering .
- Counting levels is hard when there are segmentation anomalies and sacral dysplasia.
- Conus medullaris ratio :
- the conus-to-iliac-crest distance divided by the foramen-magnum-to-conus distance;
- mean 0.184 in non-tethered vs 0.118 in tethered patients;
- AUC 0.749;
- offered as an alternative to counting vertebrae.
- What practice looks like:
- ARM-Net survey, 24 European centers :
- 96% screen every ARM patient;
- 79% start at birth;
- 50% prefer ultrasound.
- ASPN survey : all respondents order an MRI before an untethering.
Indications for untethering
- Symptomatic tethered cord: operate. This means progressive motor or sensory deficit, gait change, new foot deformity, back or leg pain, or new urological or bowel deterioration beyond the ARM baseline.
- Asymptomatic low conus or fatty filum: no consensus.
- Arguments for observation:
- Tuuha : tethered cord in 22 of 223 ARM patients (9.8%); 15 left alone remained asymptomatic (mean follow-up 2.7 years). The authors judged prophylactic surgery of minimal benefit and an expectant approach safe.
- ARM-Net : only 2 of 24 centers (8%) untether prophylactically.
- Totonelli : untethering was significantly less often needed for dysraphism with ARM than without.
- Arguments for surgery:
- Low risk:
- Teo: 17 detetherings with no complications ;
- de Beaufort: 4 uncomplicated operations .
- Progression while waiting: in a small Japanese series, 2 patients worsened before delayed surgery, and the authors recommended early untethering .
- ASPN survey : 59.1% of US pediatric neurosurgeons would offer prophylactic detethering for a low conus with fatty filum in ARM.
- Reasonable middle path (based on the evidence above, not a guideline):
- Observe an asymptomatic low conus or fatty filum with scheduled neurological, orthopedic and urodynamic review through growth and toilet training.
- Operate on clinical or urodynamic deterioration, an associated dermal sinus, or an enlarging syrinx.
- In van den Hondel's series, two asymptomatic children were untethered: one for progressive syringomyelia and one for a dermal sinus .
Outcomes: what untethering fixes
- Motor and orthopedic function improve; bowel and bladder function generally do not. This is the most consistent message:
- Tuuha :
- all 4 symptomatic patients improved in neuro/motor function;
- bowel and urinary function were unchanged in all 7 operated (mean follow-up 6.4 years).
- Totonelli 2019 :
- ARM patients had significant post-operative neuro-motor improvement;
- untethering "does not seem to benefit" intestinal or urinary symptoms.
- Uchida : orthopedic symptoms disappeared in all, but other symptoms did not.
- Teo : 3 of 7 with tethered cord syndrome improved.
- Why: much of the continence deficit in ARM comes from:
- the malformation itself;
- sacral dysplasia;
- pelvic surgery.
- Release cannot reverse these.
- Counsel families that the goal is to protect and recover neurological function. Untethering is not a treatment for ARM-related incontinence.
- After surgery, the ASPN survey found that almost all respondents follow patients clinically .
Related topics
- The Fatty Filum: the commonest filar lesion in ARM.
- Caudal Dysgenesis: sacral agenesis and caudal regression with ARM.
- Re-tethering: recurrence after untethering.
- Lipomyelomeningocele: terminal and conus lipomas.
- Dermal Sinus Tracts: a mandatory indication for exploration.
- Normal Embryological Development of the Brain and Spine: the developmental step behind this lesion.
- Tethered Cord Release: step-by-step procedure.
References
- Solomon BD. The etiology of VACTERL association: current knowledge and hypotheses. Am J Med Genet C Semin Med Genet 2018;178(4):440–446. doi:10.1002/ajmg.c.31664. PMID 30580478. verified
- Gomes A, Zapata LF, Galarreta CI, et al. Substantial incidence of bladder dysfunction in patients with VACTERL association: implications for surveillance. Am J Med Genet A 2024;194(2):320–327. doi:10.1002/ajmg.a.63443. PMID 37822287. verified
- Bowden R, Martinez NN. A systematic review of clinical and genetic approaches to VACTERL association. J Paediatr Child Health 2026 (online ahead of print). doi:10.1111/jpc.70278. PMID 41498361. verified
- Papadakis JE, Weber D, Albanese JS, et al. Incidence of idiopathic syrinx in pediatric patients diagnosed with VACTERL association. J Neurosurg Pediatr 2025;35(4):385–390. doi:10.3171/2024.10.PEDS24242. PMID 39793014. verified
- Smith CA, Nicassio LN, Rice-Townsend SE, et al. Detection and management of tethered cord in anorectal malformation: a survey of pediatric neurosurgeons in the United States. Pediatr Neurosurg 2022;57(6):434–440. doi:10.1159/000527389. PMID 36257293. verified
- de Beaufort CMC, Groenveld JC, Mackay TM, et al. Spinal cord anomalies in children with anorectal malformations: a retrospective cohort study. Pediatr Surg Int 2023;39(1):153. doi:10.1007/s00383-023-05440-y. PMID 36934393. verified
- Esposito G, Totonelli G, Morini F, et al. Predictive value of spinal bone anomalies for spinal cord abnormalities in patients with anorectal malformations. J Pediatr Surg 2021;56(10):1803–1810. doi:10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2021.05.011. PMID 34167803. verified
- Totonelli G, Messina R, Morini F, et al. Embryological and clinical implications of the association between anorectal malformations and spinal dysraphisms. Pediatr Surg Int 2017;33(8):843–847. doi:10.1007/s00383-017-4104-5. PMID 28601900. verified
- Tuuha SE, Aziz D, Drake J, et al. Is surgery necessary for asymptomatic tethered cord in anorectal malformation patients? J Pediatr Surg 2004;39(5):773–777. doi:10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2004.01.023. PMID 15137017. verified
- van den Hondel D, Sloots C, de Jong TH, et al. Screening and treatment of tethered spinal cord in anorectal malformation patients. Eur J Pediatr Surg 2016;26(1):22–28. doi:10.1055/s-0035-1563673. PMID 26394371. verified
- Jehangir S, Adams S, Ong T, et al. Spinal cord anomalies in children with anorectal malformations: ultrasound is a good screening test. J Pediatr Surg 2020;55(7):1286–1291. doi:10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2019.09.077. PMID 31708202. verified
- Kirby G, Zarifa I, Elkassaby A, et al. Systematic review of ultrasound and MRI prediction of spinal cord anomalies in children with anorectal malformations: what a pediatric urologist writing a protocol needs to know. World J Pediatr Surg 2025;8(1):e000978. doi:10.1136/wjps-2024-000978. PMID 40196182. verified
- Bischoff A, Peña A, Ketzer J, et al. The conus medullaris ratio: a new way to identify tethered cord on MRI. J Pediatr Surg 2019;54(2):280–284. doi:10.1016/j.jpedsurg.2018.10.081. PMID 30518494. verified
- Fanjul M, Samuk I, Bagolan P, et al. Tethered cord in patients affected by anorectal malformations: a survey from the ARM-Net Consortium. Pediatr Surg Int 2017;33(8):849–854. doi:10.1007/s00383-017-4105-4. PMID 28674920. verified
- Teo AT, Gan BK, Tung JS, et al. Low-lying spinal cord and tethered cord syndrome in children with anorectal malformations. Singapore Med J 2012;53(9):570–576. PMID 23023896. verified
- Totonelli G, Messina R, Morini F, et al. Impact of the associated anorectal malformation on the outcome of spinal dysraphism after untethering surgery. Pediatr Surg Int 2019;35(2):227–231. doi:10.1007/s00383-018-4400-8. PMID 30390136. verified
- Uchida K, Inoue M, Matsubara T, et al. Evaluation and treatment for spinal cord tethering in patients with anorectal malformations. Eur J Pediatr Surg 2007;17(6):408–411. doi:10.1055/s-2007-989277. PMID 18072026. verified
Verification (2026-11-17):
- Each reference's authors, title, journal, year, volume, pages, DOI and PMID were checked on PubMed. Reference 15 has no DOI listed on PubMed.
- Numbers were checked against the PubMed abstracts.
Caveats:
- The following are standard teaching, not drawn from the cited abstracts:
- the component list's "radial ray" detail;
- Fanconi anemia and other syndromes as exclusions (reference 3 recommends chromosomal breakage studies but its abstract does not name the syndromes);
- the ultrasound window of about 3–4 months;
- the list of tethered cord symptoms;
- the causes of ARM-related incontinence;
- the expected lesion types in ARM (filar lesions, low conus, terminal lipoma, caudal regression rather than open myelomeningocele), inferred from reference 8's post-primary-neurulation finding;
- the "reasonable middle path", which is the authors' synthesis, not a guideline.
- All outcome data are small retrospective series or surveys; no trial compares prophylactic untethering with observation in ARM.
- Reference 4 is a single-institution cohort, so its tethered cord rate is likely inflated by referral.
- The figure is an original schematic.